Brothers who ran filthy and pest ridden butcher’s shop prosecuted and fined

Published: Friday 2nd November 18

Two brothers who ran a filthy, dirt-encrusted and pest riddled butchers shop in Tooting have been made to pay nearly £4,600 in fines and court costs after being prosecuted by the council’s food safety team.

The men Faisal Musakhel and Zabihullah Musakheil were taken to court after hygiene inspectors discovered a catalogue of food safety breaches at their business in the Upper Tooting Road.

The inspectors were carrying out routine checks at the butcher’s shop – Noor Halal Meat at 203 Upper Tooting Road – when they found widespread evidence of a mouse infestation along with filthy food preparation and storage areas.

They found numerous mouse droppings and evidence of mouse urine on food shelves and food packets. There were dead mice below a basket of noodles displayed on the floor in the shop and below the sink in the storeroom. They also found a heavy accumulation of dead flies on food preparation surfaces.

Blood stained cardboard was left on the floor of the fresh meat storage area, while a shelf in a freezer cabinet was also found encrusted with blood.

Blood stained cardboard on floor of meat storage area

The wooden implement used to push meat through a mincing machine was covered in mouse droppings as was the area where the meat was stored before being minced. Food packets had been gnawed and chewed by rodents and even copies of old pest control records had been partly eaten by mice.

Floor and wall tiles around food preparation areas were cracked and broken allowing bacteria to accumulate.

Dirty and blood stained shelf in a freezer

As a result, the inspectors ordered the shop to close its doors immediately in order to protect public health. Initially Faisal Musakhel refused to comply but eventually relented when told of the likely legal consequences of defying this instruction. This emergency closure order was later endorsed at a court hearing which ordered the butchers to remain closed until it had been thoroughly cleaned and the pest problem eradicated.

This remedial action was completed and once the premises had been made safe it was allowed to reopen

However a further unannounced spot-check a few weeks later found conditions had deteriorated again.

The shop was once again filthy and suffering from a mouse infestation. Droppings were found on ready to eat foods such as Bombay Mix and black pepper, on food containers and on some fresh vegetables while mouse urine was found on packets of rice and around bottles of mineral water. There were also mouse droppings in boxes used to store and carry fresh meat.

The floor in the rear storeroom was covered in blood and raw meat debris as was the shop’s mincing machine while numerous dead flies were found in food storage areas indicating not only hygiene problems but also a complete lack of adequate cleaning standards.

Foodstuffs and packaging contaminated by mouse droppings, mouse urine and flies can harbour harmful bacteria, such as E coli 0157, Salmonella, Campylobacter and Leptospira which can cause diarrhoea, fever, vomiting, abdominal cramps, skin rash and even death. 

Both men pleaded guilty to seven offences under food hygiene and safety legislation when they appeared before Lavender Hill magistrates earlier this month.

Zabihullah Musakheil was fined £1,270 plus a £110 victim surcharge and ordered to pay £1,000 towards the council’s prosecution costs

Faisal Musakhel was fined £1,100 with a further £110 victim surcharge and told to pay £1,000 court costs.

The council’s consumer protection spokesman Cllr Guy Senior said: “This was appalling catalogue of failures by these men to run a safe and hygienic food business.

“Their cavalier attitude to cleaning and pest control led to serious breaches of the law and put members of the public at serious risk of harm.

“I would strongly urge other food shop proprietors and managers to take careful note of this case and take the proper steps to ensure their business is clean and safe.

“Businesses that flout the law in this way not only face a significant financial penalty but also the resulting bad publicity that these cases always bring. If food businesses want to avoid this fate they need to make sure they fulfil their legal and moral responsibilities towards their customers.”

The council carries out regular inspections of all food businesses operating in the borough. Anyone concerned with health and hygiene standards at a Wandsworth restaurant or takeaway should call (020) 8871 6166 or email foodsafety@wandsworth.gov.uk

 Make and view comments on this article



(This is only present to check if you a real person)



(Required)



(Required but not displayed on site)



(Required but not displayed with your comment. Used to help prevent spam.)



(Required)

 
(You can unsubscribe at any time)

  (Required)

 

You must carefully read and then agree to the Terms and Conditions before accessing the message board and posting a comment. If you do not wish to be bound by these Terms and Conditions, you may not access or use the message board.

If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us at press@wandsworth.gov.uk.

Recent comments

This shows how inconsiderate the English system is as the shop should have been closed down permanently immediately and fines should be 10 times of that issued. The present system allows such business owners to get away with lack of respect for others.
John

11 November 2018

This shows how inconsiderate the English system is as the shop should have been closed down permanently immediately and fines should be 10 times of that issued. The present system allows such business owners to get away with lack of respect for others.
John

11 November 2018

The total penalty of £4590 seems very low for such a repeated infringement of basic food hygiene. And, if anyone from the Council ever reads comments, is Noor Halal Meats open for business again?
Nigel Algar

5 November 2018

I presume they are halal butchers - seem to have forgotten the rules are about hygiene and protecting people
Carol Tibbs

5 November 2018

I think there is a fundemantal problem of attitude, observance and ignorance as to health and safety issues within members of the asian sub-continent community. I say this as a an Asian man of Pakistani origin myself! You will also find that a lot of these businesses cheat taxes, employ illeagal labour and flout the minimum wage laws, why should rats and cockroaches frighten them. Wansworth Council needs a to tackle these issues with a joined up multi-agency approach.
Kaleem Mirza

5 November 2018

Article doesn't say if this shop has been closed for good now.
Jo

5 November 2018

Please send an update on the Tooting High street restaurants. Eat regularly there, would like to know if their hygiene are safe. Thanks
Pamela Prescott

4 November 2018

Not surprised this place had problems, having seen the state in which meat was delivered. The fines are a joke though - £1270 and £1100 per brother - and will not be a deterrent, considering this was a particularly bad case.
Alison

2 November 2018

I am amazed and extremely disappointed that the fine for such a public health issue was as low as £4,000!
Jenefer Spells

2 November 2018