New survey required after fallen tree reveals severe root decay

Published: Friday 19th February 16

The council will commission a new professional survey of the 145 year old avenue of Horse Chestnut trees on Tooting Common after one fell over last week despite being judged to be in fair condition less than a year ago.

The fallen tree on Tooting Common.

The new survey findings will inform a public consultation, which is expected to begin in March, on what to do about the deteriorating health of Chestnut Avenue.

An inspection of the fallen tree’s upturned root ball has revealed fungal decay which could not have been detected during the 2015 above ground assessment.

The tree’s great age, structural condition and pathogens including bleeding canker infection could all have contributed to its sudden collapse. The new survey will aim to establish whether the other trees in Chestnut Avenue could be suffering from similar conditions and structural weakness.

It is already known that around a third of the Horse Chestnuts in the avenue have bleeding canker which can give rise to weakened limbs, particularly in trees of this age which cannot recover their structural strength even if the disease itself dies back.

Several heavy limbs have fallen unexpectedly from these trees despite previous maintenance aimed at taking off weaker branches.

Cllr Jonathan Cook, parks spokesman for the council, said:

“The new survey will give us a third opinion on these great trees. It will be a more detailed assessment than last year’s study and will feed into the public consultation. There are no easy choices when dealing with a situation like this but as we said back in December we will ensure local people and groups are informed and consulted before any decisions are made.”  

 View comments on this article

Comments on this news item have been closed.

If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us at

Recent comments

It would be sad to lose these magnificent horse chestnuts but appreciate need for safety. Hope remedy can be found.
Sara Jayne Stanes

27 February 2016

This article faisl to mention any of the context in which the tree fell over i.e. there were very high winds. The fact that only one fell is testament to the general condition of the trees.
Colm O'Flynn

22 February 2016

Bleeding Canker disease is a disaster for the Common and will Cllr Cook also please ensure that the tarmacking above roots of 150 year old oak tress to facilitate Formula E at Battersea Park will not have similar negative effects on these special trees. We are all for Cllr Cook keeping people informed and for consultation with local people it would help though if you did take some notice of what they say.

22 February 2016